Pyramidal thoughts

A promising title with promising content? Perhaps. If you are a supply chain or logistics professional, looking for a paper that discusses the intricacies of  managing a supply chain in a disaster area, how to prepare and how to recover, this is NOT it. However, if you are a supply chain or logistics academic or researcher, looking for a new research strand or looking for a new theoretical approach to preparedness and recovery, then yes, this is it. The supply chain crisis and disaster pyramid by R. Glenn Richey Jr is a paper that falls in the category of academically intriguing, but practically maybe not so. That said, it may very well be a future seminal paper in supply chain disaster preparedness and recovery.

Disaster preparedness and recovery

The two recent earthquakes, first in Haiti, and then in Chile have made me think about supply chains and disasters. Most recently I reflected on public-private partnerships in disaster response and recovery and how resilience is a prerequisite for surviving disasters. My interest really started last year with the earthquake in Padang, Indonesia, where I highlighted that military and civilian supply chains must work side by side.

No bedrock

Because disasters and crisis situations are so hands-on and demand immediate action they are perhaps neglected by academia, and thus left to the professionals to sort it out. Or maybe not: This paper attempts to rectify this lack of theoretical foundation by developing a novel theoretical framework to support future research in supply chain disaster and crisis situations.

Four theories – one pyramid

The framework seeks to unite four theories by constructing a pyramid with 3 planes or sections; with each section representing a perspective linking three of the four theories:

The supply chain crisis and disaster pyramid

The three bases are made up of relationship management theories (collaboration), communications theory (communication) and competing values theory (contingency). The pyramid is topped by resource management as the capstone. If Lee can come up the Triple-A supply chain, maybe this can be the Triple-C?

Collaboration

Because there are always multiple players in supply chain disaster and crisis situations, collaboration will be the glue that holds organizations together, particular if one considers the tangled web of the extended supply chain. This web is likely to provide ample research opportunities.

Communication

Supply chain disaster and crisis situations demand effective communication. Examining issues such as bi-directionality, formality, modality, and frequency will be of serious importance and provide fertile grounds for research as private and public entities attempt to understand what, when, how and how much to communicate.

Contingency

Contingency theory is based on the premise that things change, and no supply chain disaster will be like the other. One of the strongest supporting theories that could ground the contingency element is competing values theory, by suggesting that one can simultaneously pursue various different and conflicting strategic goals, regardless of the situation.

Resource management

Resources play a vital role in supply chain partnerships and it will be important to investigate how they are employed, how they are impacted and how they interact with other resources, particularly in disaster and crisis situations. That includes human resources, physical and technological resources, informational resources and financial resources.

Three research planes

The authors suggest three research areas, built on the three planes of the pyramids, i.e. the interconnections between the theories.

1 – the independents
resources – competing values – communication
How do firms re(act) as disconnected and disinformed individual organizations?

2 – the proactive partnership
resources – communication – relationship management
How can firms develop communication and collaboration?

3 – the co-opetition resource
resources – competing values – collaboration
How do firms grow their situational awareness balancing when to compete and when to collaborate?

Conclusion

Initially, I was a bit dissatisfied with the article as I was hoping for a practically relevant article, that developed a new framework based on disaster and crisis experience. However, this is a purely theoretically framework, but it is a framework that is well founded, based on the literature review. It will be interesting to see how many researchers pick up on this article and develop the suggested research strands. You can count me in…perhaps.

Reference

Richey, R.G. (2009). The supply chain crisis and disaster pyramid: A theoretical framework for understanding preparedness and recovery International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 39 (7), 619-628 DOI: 10.1108/09600030910996288

Author link

Related

Posted in ARTICLES and PAPERS
Tags: , , , ,
ARTICLES and PAPERS
Shippers, carriers and disruptions
travel-time-resilience
Both shippers and motor carriers are impacted by travel time variability, but they react differently[...]
Strategies for managing risk in multinational corporations
sumantra-ghoshal
In my post two days ago, reviewing the article by Manuj and Mentzer (2008) titled Global Supply Chai[...]
Popular in SC Resilience
supply-chain-resilience-citations
What are the Top of the Pops of Supply Chain Resilience papers? That could be the fitting title for [...]
BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS
Book review: Transport - Economics and Management
transport-economics
Kept at an executive level, Transport: An Economics and Management Perspective by David A. Hensher a[...]
Book review: Cost-Benefit Analysis
cost-benefit-analysis-book
This book, Cost Benefit Analysis: Concepts and Practice (3rd Edition), by Anthony Boardman et al. is[...]
Book Review: Managing External Risk
risk-management
I am blessed to have a college library that complies with most of my book acquisition requests and t[...]
REPORTS and WHITEPAPERS
Global Risks 2008 - A prediction come true
systemic-financial-risks
In my post on Hyper-optimization and supply chain vulnerability: an invisible global risk? I highlig[...]
Risk management - Vocabulary
iso-73-2009
What is risk management in supply chains? The more I study supply chain risk management, the more co[...]
When disaster strikes...
bridge-collapse
...how does the transportation network recover? And why are transportation networks so essential to [...]