2009/03/19 0:05 CET BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS

Book Review: Transportation Systems Security

This book, Transportation Systems Security by by Allan McDougall and Robert Radvanovsky is not what I thought it would be, but it’s not the books fault, I have to admit that much. It’s the classic misunderstanding of the difference of the terms “safety” and “security”. In English, these terms are distinctively different, in my language, Norwegian, there is only one word, “sikkerhet”, and sometimes this can be very confusing. So, what I thought was “safety” (which was what I was looking for) was in fact “security” (which was what I was NOT looking for). Nonetheless, personal disappointments aside, this book has some valid and interesting points, primarily in the introductory and theoretical parts in the beginning.

The strong side

The best chapter of the book, as far as I am concerned, is chapter 2: The Transportation System Topography, building the theoretical base for most of the book. The authors demonstrate a solid knowledge and understanding and manage to convey it in a clear and precise manner.

The weak side

The front cover gives the impression that this book deals with all transportation modes, or at least with air, sea and rail. It does not. And it is not so hands-on as I thought it would be. At times it seems to be  just meandering along without getting anywhere. I can understand that there is a lot of ground to cover, but do you really have to cover it all?

Conclusion

It is not a NO-buy, but also not a YES-buy, rather a MAYBE-buy. If you’re looking for a book on transportation vulnerability or transportation risks, this is probably not the book for you. However, if you are a transportation systems manager who wants to secure your transportation system against malicious attacks, yes, this book could be very helpful, albeit it will probably not be the one you will be using as a reference more than a few times.

Reference

McDougall A., & Radvanovsky, R. (2008) Transportation Systems Security. Boca Raton: Taylor and Francis

Author links

amazon.com

Related

More from husdal.com

BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS , , , , , ,

  • John Klein

    At first, I was skeptical about a book that could encompass all modes of transportation. Then I read Allan’s and Bob’s book.

    The book provides a fundamental understanding that everything is connected – that an event that happens in one place or location, has an impact, direct or otherwise, at another location. Rail affects trucking affects supply chain affects cost affects availability, etc. You get the point, right? The book reads like a stereo booklet, but is fairly easy to comprehend. After reading the book initially, I had to review the book several times, as it is packed with a lot of useful information for the transportation manager.

    Another nice feature is the checklist at the back of the book. The checklist – by itself – is extremely useful. Combined with its graphic counterpart, provides a roadmap as to how to go about securing your supply chain.

    If you are looking from a “transportation security” perspective, this book provides a fundamental understand about how supply chains and logistics can be secured from all perspectives (strategic, operational and tactical), providing some good insight as to “what” and “how” to secure your supply chain.

    A few chapters are a bit “clunky”, but overall, I liked the book, and would recommend this to any reader looking for a management’s perspective on supply chain security management.

Share this post

Selected blog

Gold or Dust?

Selected webinar

WTG Webinar

Selected whitepaper

Zycus Supply Risk Explosion

Selected resource

Supply Chain Response Management

Selected conference

SCL Asia 2012

Selected partner

Incapsula