Strategies for managing risk in multinational corporations

In my post two days ago, reviewing the article by Manuj and Mentzer (2008) titled Global Supply Chain Risk Management, I mentioned that they cited a paper by Ghoshal (1987) titled Global Strategy: An Organizing Framework as one of their references for listing risk management strategies. Today, I will take a closer look at that paper. The word “supply chain” doesn’t even appear once in Ghoshal’s paper, but why is this paper so interesting in a supply chain risk perspective?

Global strategy

The paper was written at the onset of globalization in 1987, when the buzzword of the day, “global strategy”, was still an emerging, but already very popular concept among managers of multinational corporations. One of the driving forces in any company is the desire to gain competitive advantage over its competitors. “Going global” is (or in 1987 still “was”) one of the means to achieve this. Today, it’s hard to imagine any corporation not being multinational in one way or the the other, or having at least some parts of its supply chain stretched around some parts of the globe. In his paper, Ghoshal provided a framework for selecting appropriate strategies when going global, and risk management was one of the strategies he looked at.

Competitive advantage – means and ends

In a multinational or global setting, competitive advantage  can be gained from three sources (means): 1) Exploiting national differences in the countries the company is involved in, 2) Benefiting from economies of scale, and 3) Exploiting synergies from economies of scope, created by the diversification of its activities. The strategic task of managing globally is to use these three sources to achieve these three strategic objectives (ends): 1) Efficiency in current operations, 2) Risk management, and 3) Innovation, learning and adaptation. In the following I will deal with managing risks only.

Managing risks

A multinational corporation faces many risks, some of which are endemic to all firms, and others which are unique to organizations operating across national boundaries. Ghoshal (1987) divides the risk into four broad categories, the same four categories that 20 years later are picked up by Manuj and Mentzer (2008).

Macroeconomic risks
– random movements in the economic environment (wages, interest rates, exchange rates, commodity prices)

Political risks
– policy actions from national governments (legal and regulatory actions, nationalization, war)

Competitive risks
– uncertainty about competitors actions or development of competitive technology

Resource risks
– lack of human resources, technology or capital

One important issue with risks is that they change over time, and the strategic task is to consider these risks jointly in the context of particular strategic decisions. It is the risks that cannot be diversified in a global environment that should be of most concern. If you’re interested in political risk in particular, I suggest you read my review of the Gower Short Business Guide on Political Risk.

Conclusion

It is interesting to note that a paper written more than 20 years ago still holds true today and still provides ample inspiration for today’s research. The reason for this may be that Ghoshal managed to synthesize the existing ideas and techniques of his time. Since then, globalization has taken many steps forward, but some aspects of globalization, like the framework in this paper, will definitely stand the test of time.

Reference

Ghoshal, S. (1987). Global Strategy: An Organizing Framework Strategic Management Journal, 8 (5), 425-440

Author links

Related

Posted in ARTICLES and PAPERS
Tags: , , , , , ,
ARTICLES and PAPERS
A conceptual framework for supply chain vulnerability
Today's article is one of the earlier works on supply chain vulnerability, published in 2000. A conc[...]
Perspectives on risk management in supply chains
Today's article is actually not an article on it's own, but an editorial to a special 2009 issue of [...]
What kind of Supplychainist are you?
With an ever-increasing number of companies outsourcing all non-core activities and  manufacturing t[...]
BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS
Book Review: Logistics Management and Strategy
Logistics Management and Strategy by Alan Harrison and Remko van Hoek does come at very hefty price,[...]
Book Review: Managing Risk and Resilience in the Supply Chain
This book is a gem. To me. Where Helen Peck in her article Reconciling supply chain vulnerability, r[...]
Supply Chain Logistics Risk in Germany
What are the most common supply chain and logistics risks that businesses and logistics providers ha[...]
REPORTS and WHITEPAPERS
Supply chain disruption risk on the rise
Global supply chains are increasingly becoming more vulnerable to potential disruption to trade, say[...]
The Benefits of Investing in Supply Chain Security
With the memory of attacks by Somali pirates still fresh in mind, supply chain security has come to [...]
The supply chain of the future
A recent report by IBM, referenced by Supply Chain Digest in IBM Lays Out its Vision for the Supply [...]