Robustness, flexibility and resilience

In a previous paper, back in 2004, I discussed the issue of Flexibility and robustness as options to reduce risk and uncertainty. Since then a new term has emerged: resilience, and today I would like to compare these three terms. Robustness is the ability to accommodate  any uncertain future events or unexpected developments such that the initially desired future state can still be reached. Flexibility is the ability to defer, abandon, expand, or  contract any investment towards the desired goal. Resilience is the ability of a system to return to its original state or move to a new desirable state after being disturbed.

Note:
This post is based on my previous work in
husdal.com: Flexibility and Robustness (2004)
The framework in this post has been further refined in later posts:
husdal.com: Robustness, resilience, flexibility and agility (2009)
husdal.com: Robust, Flexible, Agile, Resilient. What does it mean? (2015)

Flexibility and robustness are two sides of the same coin, yet at the same time two distinctively different  animals. Flexibility is the inherent capability to modify a current direction to accommodate and successfully  adapt to changes in the environment, whereas robustness refers to the ability to endure such changes  without adapting.Resilience, in essence, is the ability to survive these changes despite severe impact.

Let me explain the figure below. The thick line symbolizes the supply chain, going from its current state  “now” to a future state “future”. The  thinner arrows indicate events that may or may not disrupt the supply  chain. The thickness of the supply chain arrow indicates how seriously impacted the supply is by these  events.

A robust supply chain stays on course, so to speak. Yes, there are impacts, but they do not severely hamper the flow of the supply chain or supply network. Example: having a redundant production line, just in case.

A flexible supply chain is able to accommodate disruptions by changing its course and even the target, the flow itself (the throughput) is not impacted. Example: switching suppliers or re-designing a product.

A resilient supply chain is impacted, but it is able to come back to where it was. This may often be the case after disruptions due to natural disasters or after loosing the only single-source supplier.

Although these three terms are distinctively different it is practically impossible to draw a clear line between them as far as supply chains are concerned, saying that a supply chain is either this or that. Which strategy that works best would depend not only on the supply chain in question as a whole, but also which part of the supply chain that may be vulnerable. A best-practice supply chain would in fact encompass all three, making it robust, flexible and resilient at the same time.

For a fuller discussion of robustness, flexibility, resilience and agility, you may be interested in reading an updated version of this post, which also includes literature references: De-confusing robustness, resilience, flexibility and agility

Related

Posted in THIS and THAT
Tags: , , , , , , ,
  • Nice article! Really informative and helped me to clarify certain confusion with these terms. Thank you!

ARTICLES and PAPERS
Risk Analysis of Critical Infrastructures
The vulnerability of critical infrastructures is a recurring theme on this blog, and today's article[...]
Fragility and sustainability: emerging research areas?
Should short-term loss-minimization and short-term profit maximization really be the driving force b[...]
A new supply chain perspective: The supply chain life cycle
It is not often that I come across papers with a holistic view of the supply chain as a living and d[...]
BOOKS and BOOK CHAPTERS
Book Review: Supply Chain Risk
A comment on a a previous book review - Supply Chain Risk Managament by Donald Waters - prompted me [...]
What are Logistics Clusters?
This is a guest post by Professor Yossi Sheffi, Director, MIT Center for Transportation & Logist[...]
Book Review:Managing Risks in Supply Chains
To make up for yesterday's perhaps overly harsh critique of just one article from this book, this is[...]
REPORTS and WHITEPAPERS
The Benefits of Investing in Supply Chain Security
With the memory of attacks by Somali pirates still fresh in mind, supply chain security has come to [...]
Risk management - Vocabulary
What is risk management in supply chains? The more I study supply chain risk management, the more co[...]
Global Risk Reports
While waiting for the World Economic Forum Global Risk Report for 2009, the continuation of the Glob[...]